Molecular Genetic Evidence for a New Species of Bream of the Genus Acanthopagrus Peters (Perciformes: Sparidae)

Fishes of the genus Acanthopagrus are found throughout the coastal waters of Asia and Australia with several species being of commercial significance. In this study, genetic comparisons are made between widely disjunct populations of Acanthopagrus australis (Günther) from Australian and Taiwanese waters and among samples of A. butcheri (Munro), A. berda, (Forskal), A schlegeli (Day) and A. latus (Houttuyn) using mitochondrial DNA sequences obtained from the control region. The mean interspecific pairwise sequence divergence for all species is 17%, while the divergence between A. australis from Australia and that of Taiwan is slightly larger at 18%. These values are considerably higher than those found for intraspecific control region comparisons in some fish species. Phylogenetic analyses indicate that A. australis from Australia is more closely related to the Australian species A. butcheri than to A. australis from Taiwan. These findings suggest that the northern and southern hemisphere forms of A. australis are not monophyletic, with the former possibly representing a new undescribed species of Acanthopagrus.

Population genetic structuring in Acanthopagrus butcheri (Pisces: Sparidae): does low gene flow among estuaries apply to both sexes?

Acanthopagrus butcheri completes its entire life history within estuaries and coastal lakes of southern Australia, although adults occasionally move between estuaries via the sea. Consequently, it is expected that populations of A. butcheri in different estuaries will be genetically distinct, with the magnitude of genetic divergence increasing with geographic isolation. However, previous genetic studies of A. butcheri from southeast Australia yielded conflicting results; allozyme variation exhibited minimal spatial structuring (θ = 0.012), whereas mitochondrial DNA distinguished the majority of populations analyzed (θ = 0.263) and genetic divergence was positively correlated with geographic isolation. This discrepancy could reflect high male gene flow, which impacts nuclear but not mitochondrial markers. Here we estimated allele frequencies at five nuclear microsatellite loci across 11 southeast Australian populations (595 individuals). Overall structuring of microsatellite variation was weaker (θ = 0.088) than that observed for mitochondrial DNA, but was able to distinguish a greater number of populations and was positively correlated with geographic distance. Therefore, we reject high male gene flow and invoke a stepping-stone model of infrequent gene flow among estuaries for both sexes. Likewise, management of A. butcheri within the study range should be conducted at the scale of individual or geographically proximate estuaries for both sexes. The lack of allozyme structuring in southeast Australia reflects either the large variance in structuring expected among loci under neutral conditions and the low number of allozymes surveyed or a recent colonization of estuaries such that some but not all nuclear loci have approached migration-drift equilibrium.